My brain has a sick little talent for turning somebody else’s fucked-up behavior into a case against me. Give it one ugly night and a little time alone, and suddenly I’m cross-examining every choice I made before the shit went sideways. PEPTALK’s ‘Bad People’ understands that spiral with uncomfortable accuracy. The question becomes why I trusted him and what I should have seen sooner. That kind of self-blame is vicious because it keeps the wrong person in the defendant’s chair. Somewhere underneath all that replaying is the sentence I actually need to believe. I made a bad call. I did not cause what he chose to do.
PEPTALK wrap that headspace in polished pop that keeps moving even while the story underneath it gets fucking ugly. Pulsing synths give the track momentum while the drums push harder underneath Phoebe Sinclair’s conversational vocal. Lara Frew and Phoebe produce together as Middleman, and they understand when to let the words sit right in front of you without burying them under a giant production moment. The brightness makes the subject matter hit harder because the song never turns into a funeral for itself. It feels like the conversation with your girlfriends after the crying has stopped and somebody finally says the thing you have been scared to admit.
Advertisement
Nothing prepares me for how bluntly the first verse drops us into what happened. “You probably say its my fault, I asked for it / I could barely walk, you made a pass at me / Should’ve known, knowing your past / Still working on owning my part.” Fuck. That last line is the one that gets me because she is still trying to assign herself a percentage of responsibility two years later. Then “Moved cities, try heal from this / You chucked me in the deep then dipped / Hoping I’d sink” makes the aftermath feel huge enough to rearrange her life. Somebody else did the damage and she is still carrying the goddamn paperwork.
Calling a woman “sensitive” after putting your hands on her is the kind of bullshit that makes my blood pressure spike. “Called my ass ‘sensitive’, why your hands on it? / Straight onto defence / You said I’m not making sense / Got what you wanted then got up and left.” That is where the blame-shifting gets especially nasty. He gets to leave while she stays behind trying to untangle what happened. “I was left crying in a hotel bed / All up I’m in my head” captures the part nobody sees later when you are functioning again and everybody assumes the worst of it must be over.
Advertisement
The chorus keeps dragging her back toward one distinction she clearly needs to hold onto. “Made a bad call but it don’t / Mean I’m at fault” should be simple enough to believe, yet the next thought is already “I put / My trust before my gut.” That is the fucking trap. She knows somebody else made the harmful choice and still finds a way to prosecute herself for trusting him. By the bridge, “I have to remind myself I did all that I could do” feels like the first piece of real compassion she manages to give herself. Healing can be ugly as hell when your brain keeps reopening a case the facts already settled.
PEPTALK pair Jay-Lee Kwan on keys with Lara Frew on bass, while Phoebe Sinclair fronts the Sydney trio. Two thirds queer, two thirds POC and all three thirds female, they are building the kind of positive representation they wanted to see growing up. Songwriting sits at the center of their shit, with their work reaching artists internationally and even landing a K-pop cut through Rumble-G’s ‘Every Other.’ Lara and Phoebe also handle production together as Middleman. Their pop instincts pull from acts like MUNA and HAIM, while the friendship between the three gives PEPTALK the comfort and confidence that makes a song this vulnerable feel believable. That closeness matters on ‘Bad People.’ This feels like music made by women who trust each other enough to sit with something painful until it can finally be said out loud.
What stays with me is how hard the song works to separate regret from responsibility. I can hate the choice that put me in a room with somebody and still refuse to accept blame for what he decided to do once I was there. ‘Bad People’ lets that lesson arrive slowly because sometimes your head understands the truth months before the rest of you catches the fuck up. The bad call belongs to the past. The blame belongs somewhere else.
