It was one of those Sunday mornings where my mascara was still smudged from the night before and my phone was blowing up with “you up?” texts I should’ve ignored. I was half-wrapped in my duvet, half-scrolling through IG stories of people I don’t even like, when “We Both Know” slid into my Discover Weekly. I hit play, and —something in me shuddered. Not in a dramatic, sobbing-on-the-bathroom-floor way. More like… a subtle ache. Like I’d just remembered a dream I didn’t want to wake up from.
Jesabel’s “We Both Know” hit me mid-hangover, heart first. It’s the kind of track that doesn’t scream for attention—it haunts you softly, gently. Like a lover’s shirt you can’t bring yourself to return.
The first line—“Are you in there? Has the darkness taken hold?”—landed hard. I knew exactly who I was thinking of. That almost-love. The one that felt cosmic but crumbled in reality. A soul tie frayed by too many unread messages and too many nights sleeping on opposite sides of the bed, cold and coiled.
Advertisement
Jesabel is singing a love song but channeling a past life. Maybe several. This is her first love track and her first full writing credit, and damn, she did not come to play. You can hear it in every note. The production is soft and atmospheric—dreamy and a little eerie. Think moody synths, soft beat pulses, vocals that feel like a ghost exhaling into your ear. It’s less “radio banger” and more “late-night spell.”
And maybe that mysticism is baked into Jesabel herself. Jacksonville-based but Georgia-born, she’s not your typical storybook pop star. She didn’t grow up chasing stages or polishing her pipes at choir practice. Her path started in the rawest, most real way—losing herself in the chaos of new motherhood. That’s when music found her. Not just humming a melody or writing in secret—actually singing in front of another person for the first time, guitar in hand, daring to believe she had a voice worth hearing. And now? She’s a full-time gigging goddess, a self-taught artist pouring her soul into every line. If that’s not magic, I don’t know what is.
She says the song was inspired by the “duality of love,” and I feel that deep in my overthinking, overloving soul. There’s that ideal love—the “soul love,” the one that “lasts for lifetimes.” The kind you feel even if they’re not in your bed, not in your city, not even in your life anymore. Jesabel sings, “When I close my eyes I feel ya, even though there’s miles between us,” and I swear I could see his face. The one I always thought was it. The one who still lingers in dreams, even after I’ve blocked him twice and saged my entire apartment.
But then there’s the other side—the messy, mortal side. The “why are you giving me the silent treatment when I literally just asked a question” side. Jesabel captures that ache, too: “Can you hear me? I’ve been screaming at your soul.” Girl. Yes. Sometimes, it feels like we’re begging someone to see the version of love that exists in the stars while they’re too busy scrolling through TikTok or ghosting us for the third time this month.
This song sits in that tension. That place between unconditional soul connection and everyday relationship dysfunction. It doesn’t pretend to solve anything, and that’s what makes it feel so real. Jesabel knows it. “We don’t have the answers to the questions we keep fighting for… but we both know.” That line. That quiet surrender. Because sometimes love isn’t about clarity—it’s about recognition. Knowing there’s something deeper, even when you can’t quite make it work in this reality.
Advertisement
Vocally, Jesabel doesn’t belt—she breathes. It’s intimate. Almost whispered. Like she’s laying next to you, both of you tangled up in the dark, not touching, just knowing. Her voice is delicate but anchored, like it’s carrying centuries of heartbreak but still believes in magic.
And then comes the clincher: “I could keep lying to this heart of mine / Set the memories straight on fire / But I’ll keep running to you every time.” If I had a shot of tequila for every time I did that—I’d be dead. But I’d die dramatic and stunning, in a silk robe with glitter on my chest and a tear in my eye.
“We Both Know” isn’t about getting over someone. It’s about admitting you never really could. It’s about letting yourself believe in something bigger than the mess you made together. A love that stretches across lifetimes, even if it fumbles in the here and now.
So if you’re reading this with a text you shouldn’t answer sitting in your phone, if you’ve ever tried to unlove someone your soul won’t let go of, pour a glass of wine, dim the lights, and press play. Jesabel gets it. And we both know you do, too.
