Some guys tell you that leaving them is the biggest mistake of your life with the confidence of a man who thinks your sex life is going to file for bankruptcy without him. He calls after the breakup to explain that nobody will understand you the way he does. He seems deeply concerned that you may accidentally wander into the world and discover men who are hotter and considerably less fucking exhausting. The whole performance requires you to believe losing him is some terrible punishment. Meanwhile you’re staring at the phone thinking, please threaten me with a good time. Elle Winter’s Dream Girl was born after her long-term ex repeatedly told her she would never find anyone better, and her response was perfect – “well, a girl can dream.”
Advertisement
Lionel Crasta produces that kiss-off as big, glossy pop with enough theatrical punch to make the joke land from the cheap seats. Elle says Chappell Roan’s GRAMMY performance of Pink Pony Club helped inspire the sound, which makes perfect fucking sense. You cannot tell a man his greatest fear should actually be your dream scenario while sounding timid about it. This breakup has already happened, so we are past crying into his T-shirt and checking whether he watched the Instagram story. Elle gets the big pop production you want when you’ve finally reached the fun stage of a breakup – realizing his bullshit is actually kind of hilarious.
The ex makes his sales pitch with “You said you’re the only one who really cares / A billion guys but no one else compares.” I love a man who writes his own Yelp review. Five stars, apparently, and losing him will destroy you. Sir, should I call your mother so she can come pick up this award? Elle lets him finish talking and turns his supposed threat into the fucking chorus: “Well a girl can dream / That I won’t meet someone like you / Cause anyone like you / Is not for me.” That is the entire breakup reduced to one gorgeous misunderstanding. He thinks another him is what she should be searching for. She would apparently prefer to search for chlamydia.
And then she actually does meet somebody new. The smartest part is that his appeal comes down to one beautifully insulting qualification: “he’s nothing like you.” Elle gets to discover that being loved doesn’t have to feel exhausting, which makes “He makes it look so easy / Cause it always was” hit harder than all the post-breakup bragging ever could. Her ex told her nobody could love her. New guy apparently manages the impossible while lying beside her at home and making her laugh hard enough to cry. Somewhere an ex-boyfriend’s ego just lost Wi-Fi.
Advertisement
Elle Winter has been doing this long enough to know how to sell the punchline. The New York City-born singer-songwriter started writing and recording as a kid before becoming part of Radio Disney’s Next Big Thing program. Basically, Elle grew up learning how to write pop and eventually got handed the greatest source material available to women everywhere – a man wildly overestimating his market value. She wrote Dream Girl with Olivia Kiene and Crasta after walking away from the guy who apparently thought he was the last eligible man on Earth. Turns out he was research.
The bridge finally answers his favorite accusation. He thinks her biggest mistake was saying goodbye. Elle knows her biggest mistake was ever calling him hers. That’s the kind of clarity I personally prefer served cold with good lighting and a new man waiting at home. Dream Girl lets her ex keep insisting she’ll never find another guy like him. For his sake, I hope he eventually realizes she’s been agreeing with him the whole fucking time.
