Back when John Ritter was playing Paul Hennessy, the overprotective dad on 8 Simple Rules, the entire show ran on one beautifully doomed premise – a man trying to keep his teenage daughters from making the decisions that make being a teenage girl fun. Kaley Cuoco played Bridget, the gorgeous older one, whose love life aged Paul in real time. There’s one scene I have never let go of. A boy tells Bridget he wants to go steady, and Paul explains it means the kid won’t date anyone else, and her whole face lights the fuck up, because of course it does, being chosen exclusively is delicious. Then Paul drops the fine print: going steady means she can’t date anyone else either. You can watch the excitement drain right out of her. She was never thrilled about monogamy, she was thrilled about a boy locked down while she kept every door wide open, and the second the deal turned symmetrical the magic was gone.
And listen, I’m with Bridget. I have always been with Bridget. I watched that scene at fourteen and felt robbed on her behalf, because the one-sided arrangement where he’s devoted and I’m still browsing was never a teenage delusion to grow out of, it was a preview, and these days it’s a setup I’m running at this moment in my life, the guy who waters my plants when I’m gone has no idea his loyalty isn’t a group project. That’s the sweet network-TV version of a much filthier grown-up question: how good does it feel to be wanted exclusively when you have no intention of offering the same deal back? ‘Cuck Chair’ takes that question out of the Hennessy kitchen, checks it into a hotel room, and hands us a grown man trying to figure out where the fuck he’s allowed to sit.
That fantasy Bridget got denied has a grown-up name and for the uninitiated, it’s cuckolding: the kink where a woman fucks another man while her partner watches, and everybody in the room understands she’s the main event. The guy she brings in is called the bull, and he’s porn-star big and gym-built to match, the kind of cock and confidence a woman calls up when her partner’s been coming up short, picked specifically to deliver what he can’t. The whole thing runs on her appetite. She’s the one calling who touches her and how long her partner gets to sit there aching about it. People love to frame it as humiliation for the man, and sure, he can be into that, but make no mistake about whose pleasure the entire setup orbits. She gets two men organizing their whole night around her getting off, one earning it and one watching her get it, and she doesn’t have to pretend she’s satisfied with just one flavor when she’s clearly hungry for more. It’s a woman ordering everything she wants off the menu and making her partner thank her for the privilege of watching her eat.
Advertisement
The song opens with him walking us into his own crime scene. “First time, hotel vibe, new frontier / Welcome everybody to the Cuck Chair!” He’s the tour guide of his own demotion, lowering himself good-boy quiet into a sticky chair he calls a throne, and the thing nobody warns you about is how fucking funny it is to be the woman this song is built around while the man narrates his way to the worst seat in the room.
By the time the show’s running, she’s in full motion and he’s running on empty. “She riding the rhythm, he spitting game / I try to hide it, but I’m feeling tame / I check the minibar, but that shit is bare / Wife’s the only snack, but the bull don’t share.” She’s riding to the beat while he goes tame in the corner, and the detail that kills me is the bare minibar, this man so starved of anything to do with his hands that he goes looking for a four-dollar Toblerone and comes up empty. She’s the only snack in the room and the bull isn’t sharing, which is the most honest line in the song about whose night this is.
Then he does the thing every man in that chair does, which is phone a friend who will not save him. “Text my mate like, ‘Yo, you won’t believe’ / He sends back memes, he laughs at me / Feels like Twitch but I can’t donate / And if I could she wouldn’t even say my name.” His mate sends memes. The Twitch line is genuinely brilliant, him watching a stream he can’t influence, and the closer, that even paying in wouldn’t get her to say his name, is the kind of self-aware defeat I’d light a cigarette to. He knows there is no amount of money that buys him relevance tonight.
And then the rating, which is the funniest sign-off I’ve heard all year. “Yeah, that was my first time / Five stars for the chair / Zero stars for me.” He gives the furniture full marks and gives himself nothing, which is correct. The chair did its job. He did his, which was to sit there and watch her have the time of her life. The chair got five stars and earned every one. He rated himself zero and that’s the most accurate thing he says all night.
Advertisement
‘Cuck Chair’ comes from Viimsi Issey, a producer out of North Estonia working in alternative hip-hop, because of course a deadpan concept track about hotel-room seating logistics and not offending the bull was going to be a hip-hop track. What else would it be.
Here’s the thing about that fourteen-year-old at the kitchen table in 8 Simple Rules watching her dirty fantasy get repossessed. She grew up, and she grew up into Penny, because Cuoco kept playing her. Different sitcom, same girl, a few years older and a lot less interested in the fine print. Watch her at that Halloween party in “The Middle-Earth Paradigm” hand-feeding devoted little Leonard to a hulking ex who lifts him clean off the floor like a carry-on, and you’re watching the cuck chair before anyone gave it a name, the loyal small guy and the big hot specimen and the woman deciding which one she feels like tonight. The architype was always there. ‘Cuck Chair’ just put a hotel room around it and a man with a star rating in the seat. As for me, my plant-waterer texted to ask if I wanted him to grab my dry cleaning while he’s out, and I left him on read because the other one texted “you up?” and that’s the one I’m answering at midnight. Bridget wanted the deal at fourteen and got told no. I run it on a Tuesday and nobody’s reading me any fine print at all.





