At times in my dating history guys got hired for a job they never fucking applied for… They thought they were my boyfriend but meanwhile – somewhere inside my emotionally chaotic little brain – I had promoted them to Head of Making Everything Okay. Suddenly their texts determined my mood, their arms were the safest place on earth, and whatever bullshit was happening elsewhere felt survivable because I had them. That is an insane amount of responsibility to hand another human being, especially when you’re young enough to think falling in love and being rescued are basically the same fucking thing. Amelie Aldner’s Young Love looks back at her own similar situationship after enough time has passed to understand what actually happened. She loved him and needed him way too much. Meanwhile the poor guy was apparently supposed to save her life while also remembering date night.
The neo-soul production is warm enough to make all this emotional carnage sound almost comfortable, with guitar out front and bass and unhurried drums underneath it. Amelie sings it from the very specific hell of being old enough to understand why the relationship blew up but still remembering how it felt when you thought that man was your fucking oxygen. Years later you can finally look back without wanting him in your bed or wanting to key his car. You can admit the poor bastard was your boyfriend and somehow you had also made him responsible for keeping your entire life from falling apart.
Advertisement
She establishes how enormous the fantasy became with “Some days I look back at the time when you were mine / And I thought we’d age together like a fine wine.” Girl, of course we were aging together. I used to meet a man and mentally have us sharing a mortgage before I knew whether he replaced the toilet paper roll. Amelie gets more revealing with “I imagined a whole world where you were my king / I gave you my heart – I gave you everything.” Of course she gave him everything because she had already furnished the imaginary house and probably picked which side of the bed was hers. When your actual life feels like shit, the future you invented with some guy can become the place you mentally move into when you can’t stand being in your real one.
Then comes the confession that changes the entire breakup. “I needed you too much, in a way that no one should.” Fuck. There it is. Years later Amelie can finally see the fucked-up math. She was already hurting, then this amazing person showed up and suddenly being with him made everything feel better. “You meet this amazing person whom you fall in love with, and feel that yes, this person is everything, and will save me from all the bad feelings,” she says. Then the expectations grow “way out of proportions,” until the relationship collapses under them. I know that girl. Six months of feeling awful and then some guy makes you feel safe for a night? Congratulations sir, apparently you’re now responsible for my entire fucking will to live.
The chorus finally tells him what he could never have known while they were inside it. “We could never be the things I wanted us to be / You could never be enough to save me.” Imagine being some young guy in love and discovering you have somehow become responsible for another person’s entire emotional weather system. He takes too long to text and suddenly her Tuesday has collapsed. He needs a night alone and somehow she hears proof that the one safe thing in her life is disappearing. She’s spiraling while the poor guy is discovering that somewhere between dinner and sex he became the load-bearing wall of somebody else’s life.
Amelie gets even more generous when she imagines his side of the wreckage. “Maybe sometimes when you look back you feel bad / That you couldn’t live up to the expectations I had.” He may have walked away from that relationship believing he failed her. Then she finally gives him something her younger self couldn’t: “I want you to know I don’t blame you at all / It was too much for you to carry my fall.” There’s no villain waiting for his paragraph here. Sometimes two people can love each other and one of them arrives carrying so much pain that the relationship becomes responsible for keeping her upright. Eventually everybody gets fucking tired.
Advertisement
Amelie Aldner has been performing since she was three and professionally since 16, eventually earning a bachelor’s degree from the Norwegian Academy of Music and a master’s from the Oslo National Academy of Arts. Somewhere underneath all that training is still the girl digging through her mother’s vinyl collection, finding everyone from Whitney Houston to The Eagles and deciding music was basically everything. She says she writes to heal herself and sings to connect to the world, to live and to survive. That makes Young Love feel less like Amelie revisiting an old boyfriend for nostalgia and more like her doing what she says she has always done with music: taking the shit that hurt and figuring out what it meant.
And then she closes with five words that make the entire relationship look different: “My pain was never about you.” That’s brutal because it arrives after all the fantasies about kings and growing old together. He was standing in the middle of her pain, so of course she thought losing him caused it. Years later, Amelie can finally separate the man from the wound.
Maybe that’s the hardest part of growing up. Sometimes the person who made you feel safe never had the power to save you. He could love you and still fail at a job that was impossible from the fucking beginning. Young Love lets him resign from that job years later. Amelie keeps the heartbreak, the memories and whatever healing came from finally understanding them. He gets to go back to being the boy she once loved instead of the man who was supposed to fix everything.
